The menu at Oxford Tavern showcases a comforting mix of pub-style classics with satisfying variety. The appetizers set a cozy tone, featuring shareables like loaded potato skins, crispy calamari, and wings with a flavorful punch. Their burgers are a standout-juicy, thick, and cooked to order, often served with golden fries or onion rings. The Tavern Burger in particular delivers with melted cheddar and smoky bacon layered between a soft bun.

Seafood lovers will appreciate options like the clam cakes and chowder or the fish and chips, where the batter is crisp and the fish tender. Pasta dishes like the creamy chicken Alfredo or the shrimp scampi are hearty and flavorful, ideal for a filling dinner. Steaks and grilled items also round out the menu, including a well-seasoned ribeye and marinated grilled chicken breast.

Salads come generously portioned, with options like the grilled salmon salad or the Tavern Caesar. For those craving comfort, the mac and cheese or meatloaf dinners don’t disappoint. The menu balances variety and tradition, making Oxford Tavern a solid spot for classic American fare with a home-cooked feel.